5×5 storage in New York, NY.
A 5×5 in New York runs about $144-197/mo climate-controlled and $74-78/mo non-climate per month — promo-stripped rolling rates from Public Storage (Brooklyn Gold St, Emerson Pl, Hoboken NJ), verified 2026-06-03.
What a 5×5 actually costs here.
Outer-borough Public Storage 5x5 rolling rates run $74-78 non-climate and $144-197 climate-controlled. Manhattan-proper 5x5 inventory is dominated by Manhattan Mini Storage and CubeSmart specialty operators not in this dataset, where rolling rates can exceed $250/mo.
Why the rate is what it is.
New York metro storage supply runs ~3.6 sqft per capita per Yardi, below the national average of ~5.2 sqft. Sample state monthly avg is $174 industry-reported. Demand-supply tension keeps rent stable despite broader 2026 negative YoY trends in Sun Belt markets.
What the $1-first-month rolls to.
Public Storage Jersey City / Brooklyn 5002 2nd Ave $1-first-month promos appear at $23-26 headline. We exclude these; standard rates apply from month two. Memorial Day Sale (50%-off-4-months) had visible inventory in our 2026-06-03 fetch — those headlines roll back to standard by month five.
The local use-case mix.
Apartment overflow dominates: NY apartment median 700 sqft means closet space is at a premium. College storage (NYU, Columbia, Fordham) is a meaningful summer surge. Business records storage common in Brooklyn / Queens — Manhattan-proper space too expensive.
Operator: Public Storage (Brooklyn Gold St, Emerson Pl, Hoboken NJ)
Outer-borough rolling rates. True Manhattan inventory mostly absorbed by Manhattan Mini Storage / CubeSmart specialty operators not in this dataset.
↗ https://www.publicstorage.com/self-storage-ny-new-york/5x5-storage-units5×5 storage in New York, answered.
How much does a 5x5 storage unit cost in New York, NY?
A 5x5 storage unit in New York, NY runs about $144-197/mo climate-controlled and $74-78/mo non-climate in 2026 — promo-stripped rolling rates from Public Storage (Brooklyn Gold St, Emerson Pl, Hoboken NJ) listings, verified 2026-06-03. The rate advertised online is often a $1-first-month or half-off promo that rolls to the standard rate by month two.
Is the advertised 5x5 price in New York the real monthly rate?
Not usually. Promo lows of $23-$26 at Jersey City / Brooklyn excluded — $1-first-month. Every figure on this page is the standard rolling rate you pay from month two onward, not the online-discount headline.